COUNTERING ILLEGIBILITY: A BRIEF HISTORY OF FORCED EVICTIONS IN POSTSOCIALIST ROMANIA
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.2478/subbs-2022-0002Keywords:
forced evictions, postsocialist urban transformations, housing policy, Eastern EuropeAbstract
Forced evictions have been recognised as a relevant process in Romanian post-socialist urban transformations. Housing privatization, including restitutions, represents the key driver. Some attempts in grasping the scale of the process have already been made. This article brings extensive quantitative data stemming from national and local levels, which can support improved estimations of the scale: reports of the National Union of Bailiffs and answers to public information requests from multiple municipalities; archival data, local press monitoring and accounts of the process in the city of Cluj-Napoca. At least 100 thousand forced evictions are estimated to have taken place at national level between 1990-2017, comprising several hundred thousand individuals, the Roma population being disproportionately affected. Qualitative data produced through activist research complements the picture. The findings contribute to the debate regarding postsocialist urban transformations, indicating that the role of the state in the production of the housing market through forced evictions-based gentrification has been insufficiently acknowledged. The results are relevant to policy debates, as well as to housing activist practices.References
Aalbers, Manuel B. and Brett, Christophers (2014). “Centering housing in political economy”. Housing, theory and society, Vol 31(4):373-394
Álvarez de Andrés, Eva; María José Zapata Campos; Patrik Zapata (2014). “Stop the evictions! The diffusion of networked social movements and the emergence of a hybrid space: The case of the Spanish Mortgage Victims Group”. Habitat International, Vol 46:252-259
Baker, Alexander G. (2017). “Bailiffs at the door: work, power, and resistance in eviction enforcement”. In Brickell, Katherine, Melissa Fernández Arrigoitia și Alex Vasudevan (eds.) Geographies of Forced Eviction: Dispossession, Violence, Resistance. London: Palgrave Macmillan UK
Baker, Alexander (2020). “From Eviction to Evicting: Rethinking the Technologies, Lives and Power Sustaining Displacement.” Progress in Human Geography (online first)
Bhan, Gautam (2009). “This is no longer the city I once knew”. Evictions, the urban poor and the right to the city in millennial Delhi”. Environment & Urbanization, Vol 21(1): 127–142
Blocul pentru Locuire (2019). Raport asupra evacuărilor forțate din România petrecute în perioada 2008-2017. (en. Report on forced evictions in Romania in the 2008-2017 period). Available at: https://bloculpentrulocuire.ro/2019/04/19/raport-asupra-evacuarilor-fortate-2008-2017/
Chelcea, Liviu (2003). “Ancestors, Domestic Groups, and the Socialist State: Housing Nationalization and Restitution in Romania.” Comparative Studies in Society and History 45, no. 04 (2003): 714–40
Chelcea, Liviu, Raluca Popescu, and Darie Cristea (2015). “Who Are the Gentrifiers and How Do They Change Central City Neighbourhoods? Privatization, Commodification, and Gentrification in Bucharest.” Geografie 120, no. 2: 113–33
Comănescu, Ioan; Dinu, Demetrescu, Ioan Mihuță (1985). Legislația locativă pe înțelesul tuturor. Editura Politică
Cooper, Vickie; Kirsteen, Paton (2019). “Accumulation by Repossession: The Political Economy of Evictions under Austerity”. Urban Geography (online first)
Dan, Adrian-Nicolae; Mariana, Dan (2004). „Persoanele fără adăpost din România - o estimare a numărului acestora”. Revista Calitatea Vieţii 16, no. 1–2 (2004): 101–22
Dan, Adrian-Nicolae (2018). “Homelessness Prevention in the Context of Evictions in Romania.” Sociology and Social Work Review Vol 1:6-29
Dohotaru, Adrian; Hajnalka Harbula; Enikő Vincze (eds.) (2015). Pata. Cluj-Napoca: Efes
Gerull, Susanne (2014). “Evictions Due to Rent Arrears: A Comparative Analysis of Evictions in Fourteen Countries.” Part B Vol 8(2):19
Hartman, Chester; David, Robinson (2003). “Evictions: The Hidden Housing Problem.” Housing Policy Debate Vol 14(4):461–501
Lancione, Michele (2019). “The politics of embodied urban precarity: Roma people and the fight for housing in Bucharest, Romania”. Geoforum Vol 101:182-191
Maharawal, Manissa M.; Erin, McElroy (2017). “The Anti-Eviction Mapping Project: Counter Mapping and Oral History toward Bay Area Housing Justice”. Annals of the American Association of Geographers Vol 108(2):380-389
Nelson, Kyle (2019). “The Microfoundations of Bureaucratic Outcomes: Causes and Consequences of Interpretive Disjuncture in Eviction Cases”. Social Problems Vol 68(1):1-16
Pasti, Vladimir (2006). Noul capitalism românesc. Polirom: Iași
Paton, Kirsteen; Vickie, Cooper (2016). “It’s the State, Stupid: 21st Gentrification and State-Led Evictions”. Sociological Research Online Vol 21(3):1–7
Petrovici, Norbert (2012). “Workers and the City: Rethinking the Geographies of Power in Post-Socialist Urbanisation.” Urban Studies 49, no. 11:2377–97
Popovici, Veda (2020). “Residences, restitutions and resistance - A radical housing movement’s understanding of post-socialist property redistribution”. City - Analysis of Urban Change, Theory, Action Vol 24(1-2):1-15
Porton, Adam; Ashley, Gromis; Matthew, Desmond (2020). “Inaccuracies in Eviction Records: Implications for Renters and Researchers.” Housing Policy Debate (online first)
Romani Criss (2004). Protecția dreptului la locuință al romilor din România - Manual de educare privind legislația internațională și dreptul la o locuință adecvată. Available at: https://tinyurl.com/6t2wub9t
Rughinis, Ana Cosima (2004). “Social Housing and Roma Residents in Romania,”. Open Society Institute and Center for policy Studies, Central European University
Stan, Lavinia (2006). “The Roof over Our Heads: Property Restitution in Romania.” Journal of Communist Studies and Transition Politics 22, no.2:180–205
Seymour, Eric; Joshua, Akers (2021). “Building the Eviction Economy: Speculation, Precarity, and Eviction in Detroit”. Urban Affairs Review Vol 57(1):35–69
Soederberg, Susanne (2018). “Evictions: A Global Capitalist Phenomenon”. Development and Change Vol 49(2):286-301
Swinkels, Rob (ed.) (2014). Atlasul zonelor urbane marginalizate din România. Washington: Banca Mondială.
Vincze, Enikő (2013). “Socio-Spatial Marginality of Roma as Form of Intersectional Injustice”. Studia Universitatis Babes-Bolyai Sociologia Vol 58(2):217-242
Vincze, Enikő; George Iulian, Zamfir (2019). “Racialized housing unevenness in Cluj-Napoca under capitalist redevelopment”. City - Analysis of Urban Change, Theory, Action Vol 23(4-5):2-22
van Baar, Huub. (2016). “Evictability and the Biopolitical Bordering of Europe”. Antipode Vol 49(1):212-230
van Baar, Huub; Ana Ivasiuc, Regina Kreide (2019). “The European Roma and their securitization: Contexts, junctures, challenges”. În van Baar, Huub; Ana Ivasiuc, Regina Kreide (eds) The Securitization of the Roma in Europe. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham
von Otter, Cecilia; Olof, Bäckman; Sten-Åke, Stenberg; Carin, Qvarfordt Eisenstein (2017). “Dynamics of Evictions: Results from a Swedish Database”. European Journal of Homelessness. Vol 11(1):1-23
Vrăbiescu, Ioana (2017). “Non- and Dedocumenting Citizens in Romania.” Focaal 2017(77):22–35
Wacquant, Loïc (2019). “Class, Ethnicity and State in the Making of Urban Marginality”. In John Flint and Ryan Powell (eds.) Class, Ethnicity and State in the Polarized Metropolis Putting Wacquant to Work. Palgrave MacMillan, Cham
Watt, Paul (2018). “ ‘This Pain of Moving, Moving, Moving:’ Evictions, Displacement and Logics of Expulsion in London.” L’Année Sociologique Vol 68(1):67
Zamfir, George Iulian (2016). „Cluj Capitală Culturală sau justiție culturală ca răspuns la injustiții sociale?”. Gazeta de Artă Politică. Available at: http://artapolitica.ro/2016/11/13/clujcapitala-culturala-sau-justitie-culturala-ca-solutie-la-injustitii-sociale/
Zamfirescu, Irina; Liviu, Chelcea (2020). “Evictions as infrastructural events”. Urban Geography (online first)
Zoon, Ina, and Mark Norman Templeton (2001). On the Margins: Roma and Public Services in Romania, Bulgaria, and Macedonia: With a Supplement on Housing in the Czech Republic. New York: Open Society Institute
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Studia Universitatis Babeș-Bolyai Sociologia
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
