ANDREÏ MAKINE – FROM ANONYMITY TO LITERARY FAME

Authors

  • Constantin TONU Department of Comparative Literature, Faculty of Letters, Babeș-Bolyai University, Cluj-Napoca, Romania. Email: constantin.tonu@ubbcluj.ro. https://orcid.org/0009-0009-1821-4000

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.24193/subbphilo.2024.2.07

Keywords:

pseudo-translation, hybrid identity, personal mythology, slavophilia, francité

Abstract

Andreï Makine – From Anonymity to Literary Fame. The aim of this article is to analyse the strategies that enabled Andreï Makine to go from being a penniless Russian immigrant living in a Parisian cemetery to becoming a celebrity in the French literary world. The first aspect to be considered is the use of pseudo-translation. Unlike another Russian writer in exile, Alexander Solzhenitsyn, who always believed that his works would be read by his compatriots and have an impact on the Russian cultural space, Makine, who settled in France in 1987, decided to write in French, mainly for a French readership. However, his first two novels were rejected by the Parisian publishers who did not believe that a Russian could write so well in French, so Makine had to create fictitious translators in order to get his texts published. Another significant factor is the way in which he exploited his biographical aspects to create a personal mythology. The third, and perhaps most important, factor that has contributed to Makine’s consecration in the French cultural space is the way he describes his country of origin (he has been accused of creating an image of Russia that would be pleasing to Western eyes) and his host country, praising both the French language and, as the title of one of his books puts it, “this France that we forget to love".

Andrei Makine – de la anonimitate la faimă literară. Acest articol își propune să analizeze factorii și strategiile care au facilitat transformarea lui Andreï Makine, un imigrant rus fără bani și fără acte care trăia într-un cimitir parizian, într-o celebritate a spațiului literar francez. Primul aspect care va fi abordat este utilizarea pseudotraducerii. Spre deosebire de un alt scriitor rus exilat, Alexander Soljenițîn, care a crezut întotdeauna că lucrările sale vor fi citite de compatrioții săi și vor avea un impact asupra spațiului cultural rusesc, Makine, stabilit în Franța din 1987, a decis să scrie în franceză în principal pentru un public francez. Cu toate acestea, primele două romane ale sale au fost respinse de editorii parizieni care nu credeau că un rus poate scrie atât de bine în franceză. În consecință, Makine a fost nevoit să creeze traducători fictivi pentru a-și publica romanele. Al doilea aspect semnificativ este modul în care scriitorul și-a instrumentat elementele biografice pentru a crea o mitologie personală. În cele din urmă, al treilea și poate cel mai important factor care a contribuit la consacrarea lui Makine în spațiul cultural francez este modul în care el descrie țara sa de origine (a fost acuzat că a reprezentat Rusia clișeic, pentru a fi placul occidentalilor) și țara gazdă, elogiind atât limba franceză, cât și, cum spune titlul uneia dintre cărțile sale, „această Franță pe care uităm să o iubim”.

Cuvinte-cheie: pseudotraducere, identitate hibridă, mitologie personală, slavofilie, francitate

Article history: Received 11 May 2024; Revised 04 June 2024; Accepted 12 June 2024; Available online 25 June 2024; Available print 30 June 2024.

References

Barguillet Hauteloire, Armele. 2016. “Andreï Makine ou l’héritage accablant”. Interligne, 4 mars 2016, https://interligne.over-blog.com/article-liste-des-articles-de-la-rubrique-litterature-88826012.html.

Barthes, Roland. 1997. “The Death of the Author.” In Image Music Text, essays selected and translated by Stephen Heath, 142-148. London: Fontana Press.

Bărbuceanu, Ionela. 2016. Imagini ale Rusiei la Andrei Makine. Editura Universității din București.

Casanova, Pascale. 2004. The World Republic of Letters. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Chilea-Matei, Cristina-Ioana. 2010. “Problématique de l’identité littéraire. Comment devenir écrivain français. Andrei Makine, Vassilis Alexakis, Milan Kundera et Amin Maalouf.” PhD diss., département de littérature française, Université Jean Monnet / Université Alexandru Ioan Cuza.

Clément, Murielle Lucie. 2008. “Andreï Makine. Présence de l’absence : une poétique de l’art (photographie, cinéma, musique).” PhD diss., Université d’Amsterdam, Département des Lettres et culture françaises.

Clément, Murielle Lucie. 2011. Andreï Makine: l’ekphrasis dans son œuvre. Amsterdam : Rodopi.

Derrida, Jacques. 2001. Writing and Difference. Translated, with an introduction and additional notes, by Alan Bass. London: Routledge Classics.

Duffy, Helena. 2018. World War II in Andreï Makine’s Historiographic Metafiction. Leiden, Boston: Brill Publishers.

Gillespie, David. 2010. “Bartavels, Ortolans and Borshch: France and Russia in the Fictional Worlds of Andreï Makine.” Australian Slavonic and East European Studies, Vol. 24, No. 1-2: 1-18.

Gillespie, David. 2012. “Border Consciousness in the Fictional Worlds of Andreï Makine.” Journal of Siberian Federal University. Humanities & Social Sciences, No. 5: 798-811.

Harmath, Erzsebet. 2011. Andrei Makine, “Geopoetique d’un ecrivain mineur.” PhD diss., Szeget.

Laurent, Thierry. 2006. Andreï Makine: Russe en exil. Paris : Connaissances et Savoirs.

Lievois, Katrien. 2013. “Pseudo-traduction et image d’auteur : le cas Andreï Makine.” Les Lettres romanes, vol. 67, issue 3-4: 447-462.

Makine, Andreï. 1998. Dreams of my Russian Summers. Translated by Geoffrey Strachan. New York: Simon & Schuster.

Makine, Andreï. 2006. Cette France qu’on oublie d’aimer. Paris : Flammarion.

Makine, Andreï. 2016. “Ma vie de la rue à l’Académie.” Interview by Patrick Simonin. Youtube, posted by L’invité on 22.12.2016. Audio 0:45-1:00, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJqRcL1SNJE.

Makine, Andreï. 2019. “Rencontre avec Andreï Makine.” Youtube, 1:02:35-1:03:02, posted by École nationale des chartes – PSL on 24.04.2019, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idS--aMv6bU&t=554s.

Makine, Andreï. 2023. “Andreï Makine, le plus russe des écrivains français.” Interview by Louise Dupont. France24, posted on 17.01.2023, https://www.france24.com/fr/%C3%A9missions/%C3%A0-l-affiche/20230117-andre%C3%AF-makine-le-plus-russe-des-%C3%A9crivains-fran%C3%A7ais.

McCall, Ian. 2006. “Translating the Pseudotranslated: Andreï Makine’s La Fille d᾽un héros de l᾽Union soviétique”. Forum for Modern Language Studies, vol. 42, n° 3: 286-297.

Mélat, Hélène. 2002. “Andreï Makine: Testament français ou Testament russe?” Revue Russe, no. 21: 41-49.

Nazarova, Nina. 2005. Andreï Makine, deux facettes de son oeuvre. Paris: L’Harmattan.

Olteanu, Antoaneta. 2009. “Andreï Makine între Rusia şi Franţa, între Orient şi Occident”. In Romanoslavica XLIV, 143-148. Editura Universității din București.

Parry, Margaret, Marie-Louise Scheidhauer, and Edward T. Welch (eds.). 2005. Andreï Makine, Perspectives Russes. Paris: L’Harmattan.

Safran, Gabriella. 2003. “Andreï Makine’s Literary Bilingualism and the Critics”. Comparative Literature, Vol. 55, No. 3: 246-265.

Sala, Dana. 2009. “Andrei Makine, «Testamentul francez» – identitatea ca descoperire a feminităţii”. In Teze şi antiteze ale actualităţii, edited by Graţian Cormoş, 53-56. Cluj-Napoca: InfoData.

Scheidhauer, Marie-Louise, Edward T. Welch, and Margaret Parry (eds.). 2004. Andreï Makine : la rencontre de l’Est et de l’Ouest. Paris : L’Harmattan.

Sylwestrzak-Wszelaki, Agata. 2010. Andreï Makine: L’identité problématique. Paris : L’Harmattan.

Talmor, Sascha. 1996. “Speak, Memory: Andreï Makine’s Le testament français.” The European Legacy: Toward New Paradigms, 1:7, 2094-2109.

Taras, Ray. 2000. “«A la recherche du pays perdu»: Andrei Makine’s Russia.” East European Quarterly, Vol. 34, Issue 1, (Spring): 51-79.

Tolstaya, Tatyana. 1997. “Love Story.” New York Review of Books, https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1997/11/20/love-story/.

Tolstaya, Tatyana. 1998. “Russkii chelovek na randevu.” Znamia, No. 6 200-09 [Толстая, Татьяна. 1998. “Русский человек на рандеву.” Знамя, No. 6], https://znamlit.ru/publication.php?id=500.

Toma, Dolores, and Diana Samarineanu. 2017. Andreï Makine, hétérotopies, hétérochronies. Paris: L’Harmattan.

Tonu, Constantin. 2023. „Slavophile elements in Andrei Makine prose.” Caietele Echinox, vol. 45: 125-139.

Wanner, Adrian. 2002. “Gained in Translation: Andreï Makine’s Novel Le Testament Francais.” Literary Imagination, vol. 4, issue 1: 111-126.

Zlobina, Maya. 1996. “V poiskakh utrachennykh mgnovenii”. Novyi mir, No. 10 [Злобина, Майя. 1996. “В поисках утраченных мгновений”. Новый мир], https://nm1925.ru/articles/1996/199610/v-poiskakh-utrachennykh-mgnoveniy-5351/.

Downloads

Published

2024-06-25

How to Cite

TONU, C. . (2024). ANDREÏ MAKINE – FROM ANONYMITY TO LITERARY FAME. Studia Universitatis Babeș-Bolyai Philologia, 69(2), 125–136. https://doi.org/10.24193/subbphilo.2024.2.07

Issue

Section

Articles