A CANONICAL AND THEOLOGICAL RECONSIDERATION OF THE DOCUMENT “THE IMPORTANCE OF FASTING AND ITS OBSERVANCE TODAY” OF THE HOLY AND GREAT COUNCIL OF CRETE

Răzvan  PERȘA

doi:10.24193/subbto.2018.2.08

Authors

Răzvan PERȘA Reverend, Assistent Professor PhD, Faculty of Orthodox Theology, Babeș-Bolyai University, Cluj-Napoca, Romania. Email: persarazvan@gmail.com. https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3840-7028

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.24193/subbto.2018.2.08

Keywords:

Holy and Great Council, Fasting, Canon Law, canons, Tradition, postmodern society

Abstract

In this paper, I tried to examine the first four paragraphs of the document The Importance of Fasting and Its Observance Today, of the Holy and Great Council of Crete (2016), from a canonical and theological point of view, by taking into consideration its development, the pre-conciliary debates, and its final form. Having in mind this vast period of time needed for the final form of the text of the Holy and Great Council, we can assert the total victory of the theologians and circles with conservative theological visions, because the idea of changing and adapting fasting periods to current social circumstances was totally removed from the inter-Orthodox debate. The official document of the Holy and Great Council is an attempt of theological argumentation of the practice of fasting, highlighting, with several biblical and patristic quotations, the general importance of the institution of fasting, but without any practical clarification. The text contains more than 26 biblical, patristic and liturgical quotations. Almost 40% of the text of the document is represented by quotes and different references, showing a lack of originality and actuality. Despite that, the documents emphasizes that fasting in the Orthodox Church has many dimensions: historical-theological (fasting as divine commandment given in Paradise); ascetic-spiritual (fasting as great spiritual endeavor and the foremost expression of the Orthodox ascetic ideal); canonical (the foundation of fasting are the apostolic precepts, the synodal canons, and the patristic tradition as a whole); soteriological (the great significance of fasting for our spiritual life and salvation); and liturgical (fasting is according to the liturgical Tradition of the Orthodox Church, culminating with the Holy Eucharist).

References

“3. Vorkonziliare Panorthodox Konferenz.” Una Sancta 42 (1987): 14-28

“Autonomy and the Means by Which It Is Proclaimed.” The Canadian Journal of Orthodox Christianity 11, no. 3 (September 2016), 95–105.

“Encyclical of the Holy and Great Council of the Orthodox Church: Crete 2016.” The Ecumenical Review 68, no. 2–3 (December 2016): 291–304.

“Encyclical of the Holy and Great Council of the Orthodox Church.” The Canadian Journal of Orthodox Christianity 11, no. 3 (September 2016): 71–94.

“Message of the Holy and Great Council of the Orthodox Church.” The Canadian Journal of Orthodox Christianity 11, no. 3 (September 2016): 57–70.

“Textes Officiels Adoptés Par Le Concile.” Contacts 255, no. 68 (2016), 255–322.

Afanasiev, Nicolas. “The Canons of the Church: Changeable or Unchangeable.” St. Vladimir’s Theological Quarterly 11(1967): 54-68.

Cavarnos, Constantine. Fasting and Science: A Study of the Scientific Support and Patristic Foundation for Fasting in the Orthodox Church. 2nd edition. Calif: Center for Traditionalist, Etna, 1998.

Chițescu, Nicolae. “Note și impresii de la Conferința Panortodoxă de la Rhodos.” Biserica Ortodoxă Română, no. 9-10 (1961): 887.

Ciobotea, Dan-Ilie. “Spre Sfântul și Marele Sinod al Ortodoxiei.” Biserica Ortodoxă Română, no. 11-12 (1982): 942-945.

Desnitsky, Andrei. “Die Russische Orthodoxe Kirche vor dem Panorthodoxen Konzil.” Religion und Gesellschaft in Ost und West 2 (2016): 7–8.

Dulles, Avery. “Jus divinum as an Ecumenical Problem.” Theological Studies 38 (1977): 681-708.

Episkepsis, no. 368 (1986): 10-11.

Episkepsis, no. 369 (1986): 2-28.

Erickson, John, “Oikonomia in Byzantine Canon Law.” In Law, Church, and Society. Essays in Honor of Stephan Kuttner, edited by Kenneth Pennington, Robert Somerville. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1977.

Florian Schuppe. Die pastorale Herausforderung – orthodoxes Leben zwischen Akribeia und Oikonomia: theologische Grundlagen, Praxis und ökumenische Perspektiven. Würyburg: Augustinus-Verlag, 2006.

Goreanu, Veniamin. “The Settlement of Canonic Tradition in the Document ‘The Importance of Fasting and Its Observance Today.’” Studia Universitatis Babes-Bolyai Theologia Orthodoxa, 62, no. 1 (27 june 2017): 89-91.

Hamilkar Alivisatos, “Wie verständigen sich die verschiedenen orthodoxen Kirchen über allgemeine und eilige fragen (Kalenderreform, Ehe der Geistlichen, fasten etc.) im Falle eines Aufschubs des ökumenischen Konzils?” In Procès-verbaux du Premier Congrès de Théologie Orthodoxe: à Athènes; 29 Novembre – 6 Décembre 1936, edited by Hamilkar Alivisatos. Athènes: Pyrsos, 1939.

Hollerbach, Alexander. “Göttliches und Menschliches in der Ordnung der Kirche.” In Mensch und Recht: Festschrift für Erik Wolf zum 70. Geburtstag, edited by Alexander Hollerbach. Frankfurt am Main: Klostermann, 1972.

Holman, Susan and Mark Delcogliano. On Fasting and Feasts: Saint Basil the Great. New York: Saint Vladimir’s Seminary Press, 2013.

Ioniță, Viorel, ed. Towards the Holy and Great Synod of the Orthodox Church: The Decisions of the Pan-Orthodox Meetings since 1923 until 2009. Freiburg, Base: Reinhardt, Friedrich, 2014.

———. “On the Way to the Holy and Great Synod of the Orthodox Church.” In Orthodoxie im Dialog: Historische und aktuelle Perspektiven, edited by Reinhard Flogaus and Jennifer Wasmuth. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 2015.

———. Hotărârile întrunirilor panortodoxe din 1923 până în 2009: spre Sfântul şi Marele Sinod al Bisericii Ortodoxe. București: Basilica, 2013.

Jensen, Anne. Die Zukunft der Orthodoxie: Konzilspläne und Kirchenstrukturen. Zürich: Benziger, 1986.

Jillions, John A. “Review essay: A quest for reform in the Orthodox Church; the 1923 Pan-Orthodox Congress.” Studia Canonica 41, no. 2 (2007): 507-514.

Jovic, Rastko. “The Importance of Fasting and Its Observance for Tomorrow.” Studia Universitatis Babes-Bolyai Theologia Orthodoxa 62, no. 1 (28 iunie 2017): 103-114.

Kallis, Anastasios. Auf dem Weg zu einem Heiligen und Großen Konzil: ein Quellen- und Arbeitsbuch zur orthodoxen Ekklesiologie. Münster: Theophano-Verlag, 2013.

Kazarian, Nicolas. “Всеправославный собор: формирование новой православной геополитики [The Pan-Orthodox Council: Shaping New Orthodox Geopolitics]. Государство, религия, церковь в России и за рубежом, 1 (2016): 102–26;

Khalil, Issa J. “The Orthodox Fast and the Philosophy of Vegetarianism.” The Greek Orthodox Theological Review 35, no. 3 (1990): 237-259.

Kistner, Peter. Das göttliche Recht und die Kirchenverfassung. Band 1. Münster: LIT Verlag, 2009.

M., Gr. “Expunerea Prea Sfințitului Episcop Dr. Nicolae Corneanu al Aradului despre Conferința de la Rhodos.” Mitropolia Ardealului, no. 11-12 (1961): 841.

Madden, Rita. Food, Faith, and Fasting: A Sacred Journey to Better Health. Ancient Faith Publishing, 2015.

Melloni, Alberto, ed. The Great Councils of the Orthodox Churches. Crete 2016. Corpus Christianorum Conciliorum Oecumenicorum Generaliumque Decreta 4.3. Brespol, 2017.

Muksuris, Stelyios S. et al. “Reflection on the Pre-conciliar Document: The Importance of Fasting and its observance today.” In Toward the Holy and Great Council. Theological Reflections, edited by Nathanael Symeonides ed. Department of Inter-Orthodox Ecumenical and Interfaith Relations, 2016.

Munteanu, Eugen. Lexicologie biblică românească. București: Humanitas, 2008.

Necula, Nicolae. “Învățătura despre post în Biserica Ortodoxă.” Studii Teologice, no. 7-8 (1984): 514-520.

Papadaki, A. et al. “Calcium, nutrient and food intake of Greek Orthodox Christian monks during a fasting and non-fasting week.” Public Health Nutrition 11, no. 10 (October 2008): 1022-1029.

Papadaki, A. et al., “Differences in nutrient intake during a Greek Orthodox Christian fasting and non-fasting week, as assessed by a food composition database and chemical analyses of 7-day weighed food samples.” Journal of Food Composition & Analysis 24, no. 1 (February 2011): 22-28.

Papathanasiou, Athanasios. “Christian fasting in postmodern society: considering the criteria.” St Vladimir’s Theological Quarterly 60, no. 1-2 (2016): 249-268.

———. “Christian fasting in postmodern society: considering the criteria.” St Vladimir’s Theological Quarterly 60, no. 1-2 (2016): 249-256.

Pavel, Constantin. “Posturile rânduite de Biserica Ortodoxă în condițiile de viață actuale ale credincioșilor.” Studii Teologice, no. 5-8 (1977): 421-435.

Photii. Bishop of Triaditza. “The 70th Anniversary of the Pan-Orthodox Congress in Constantinople: A Major Step on the Path Towards Apostasy.” Orthodox Life 44, no. 2 (March 1994): 36-48.

Plămădeală, Antonie. “A treia Conferință Panortodoxă Preconciliară.” Biserica Ortodoxă Română, no. 9-10 (1986): 40.

Rahner, Karl. “Über den Begriff des Ius Divinum” im katholischen Verständnis.” In Existenz und Ordnung. Festschrift für Erik Wolf zum 60. Geburtstag, edited by Thomas Würtenberger, Werner Maihofer, and Alexander Hollerbach. Frankfurt am Main: Klostermann, 1962.

Reijnen, Anne Marie. “Fasting-some Protestant remarks: ‘not by bread alone’: an argument for the contemporary value of Christian fasting.” St Vladimir’s Theological Quarterly 60, no. 1-2 (2016): 269-278.

Rhalles, Georgios and Michael Potles, eds. Σύνταγμα τῶν θείων καὶ ἱερῶν κανόνων. Volume 2. Atena, 1852.

Richter, Gerhard. Oikonomia. Der Gebrauch des Wortes Oikonomia im Neuen Testament, bei den Kirchenvätern und in der theologischen Literatur bis ins 20. Jahrhundert. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 2005.

Sarri, Katerina O. et al. “Effects of Greek Orthodox Christian Church fasting on serum lipids and obesity.” BMC Public Health 3 (January 2003): 16-8.

Schmemann, Alexander. The Great Lent. Journey to the Pascha. St. Vladimir’s Seminary Press, 1974.

Secrétariat pour la préparation du Saint et Grand Concile de L’Église Orthodoxe, ed. IIe Conférence panorthodoxe préconciliaire. Actes (3-12 septembre 1982). Vol. VIII. Chambésy-Genève: Centre orthodoxe du Patriarcat Œcuménique, 1994.

———, ed. IIIe Conférence panorthodoxe préconciliaire. Actes (28 octobre – 9 novembre 1986). Synodika X. Chambésy-Genève: Centre orthodoxe du Patriarcat Œcuménique, 2014.

———, ed. Ε’ Προσυνοδική Πανορθόδοξος Διάσκεψις, Σαμπεζύ Γενεύης, 10-17 Ὀκτωβρίου 2015. Synodika XIII. Chambésy-Genève: Centre orthodoxe du Patriarcat Œcuménique, 2016.

Sf. Vasile cel Mare, Scrieri, partea I, Omilii la Hexaemeron, Omilii la Psalmi, Omilii și cuvântări. Părinți și scriitori bisericești 17. Translated by Pr. Dumitru Fecioru. București: Editura Institutului Biblic și de Misiune al Bisericii Ortodoxe Române, 1986.

Soare, Gheorghe. “De la Vatopedi la Rhodos (From Vatopedi to Rhodos).” Biserica Ortodoxă Română LXXIX, no. 9-10 (1961): 844.

Stan, Liviu. “Soborul panortodox de la Rhodos.” Mitropolia Olteniei, no. 10-12 (1961): 732-733.

Thurn, Hans. Oikonomia von der frühbyzantinischen Zeit bis zum Bilderstreit: Semasiologische Untersuchung einer Wortfamilie. München, 1961.

Viscuso, Patrick. A Quest for Reform of the Orthodox Church: The 1923 Pan-Orthodox Congress, An Analysis and Translation of Its Acts and Decisions. Berkeley, Calif: InterOrthodox Press, 2006.

Κολοβοπούλου, Μαρίνα. “«Ἡ σπουδαιότης τῆς νηστείας καὶ ἡ τήρησις αὐτῆς σήμερον». Δρώμενα ἀπὸ τὴν πορεία πρὸς τὴν Ἁγία καὶ Μεγάλη Σύνοδο τῆς Ὀρθοδόξου Ἐκκλησίας.” Θεολογία 87, no. 1 (2016): 198-200.

Παπαδοπούλου, Ἀντωνίου. “Ἡ προετοιμαζομένη Ἁγία καί Μεγάλη Σύνοδος τῆς κατ’ Ἀνατολάς Ὀρθοδόξου Ἐκκλησίας ἔναντι τῶν περί νηστείας Ἐκκλησιαστικῶν Διατάξεων.” In Νηστεία καί πνευματική ζωή (Χρονικόν, εἰσηγήσεις, πορίσματα Ἱερατικοῦ Συνεδρίου τῆς Ἱερᾶς Μητροπόλεως Δράμας, ἔτους 1989). Δράμα, 1989.

Πρακτικά καὶ Ἀποφάσεις τοῦ ἐν Κωνσταντινουπόλει Πανορθοδόξου Συνεδρίου (10 Μαϊου – 8 Ἰουνίου 1923). Ἐν Κωνσταντινουπόλει: ἐκ τοῦ Πατριαρχικοῦ Τυπογραφείου. 1923.

Πρός τήν Μεγάλην Σύνοδον, Εἰσηγήσεις τῆς Διορθοδόξου Προπαρασκευαστικῆς Ἐπιτροπῆς ἐπί τῶν ἕξ θεμάτων τοῦ πρώτου σταδίου. Chambésy-Genève: Orthodox Centre of the Ecumenical Patriarchate, 1971.

Σκαλτσής, Παναγιώτης. “Ἡ νηστεία κατά τίς Προσυνοδικές Συζητήσεις.” Θεολογία, 86, no. 4 (2015): 213-220.

Документи Святого і Великого Собору Православної Церкви. Крит, 2016. Translated by Юрій Вестель, Дмитро Каратєєв. Відкритий Православний Університет Святої Софії Премудрості, ДУХ I ЛIТЕРА, 2016.

Web sources:

https://mospat.ru/en/2016/02/02/news127681/.

https://www.holycouncil.org/-/news-bulletin-number-3.

https://www.holycouncil.org/.