The Mission of Christians for Reconciliation in Europe

Authors

  • Dieter BRANDES Lucian Blaga University of Sibiu, Faculty of Orthodox Theology, Email: dieter.brandes@gmx.de

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.24193/subbtref.65.1.17

Keywords:

Reconciliation, Healing of Memories, Historical wounds, Genocide, Charta Oecumenica

Abstract

The old historical wounds of Europe are century-old wounds like the “Northern Ireland conflict”, the Russia–Finland conflict, the Poland–Germany–Russia conflict, the long-lasting conflict between Ottomans, Hungary, and later, the Habsburg and the Russian Empire, but also the thousand-year-old religious borderline between Eastern and Western culture. Moreover, the first half of the 20th century in (the Christian) Europe is characterized by wars and genocide in a terrible, hitherto unknown dimension. About 10 million people died in World War I and about 50 million in World War II. Countries all over Europe like Austria, Belgium, Croatia, Czechoslovakia, Denmark, Finland, France, Great Britain, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Romania, Russia, Serbia, Turkey, and Ukraine were involved in these war-related events. Many unhealed mental wounds are still deeply rooted in the hearts of individuals and peoples. Unhealed wounds also remained concerning the genocides of the 20th century, like the Armenian genocide, the Holodomor in Ukraine, the Holocaust against Jews and Gypsies, the genocide against Tatars in the Crimean region. Finally, let us remember the million fold wounds that arose from the communist dictatorships. After World War II, we have to mention the wounds inflicted by many additional European conflicts like the ones between Azerbaijan and Armenia, Georgia and Russia, Ukraine and Russia, the Bosnia–Croatia–Serbia conflict regarding the dissolution of the old state of Yugoslavia, the conflict between Greeks and Turks regarding Northern Cyprus, the Moldova–Russia conflict regarding Transdniestria etc.

The need for healing and reconciliation in our broken world cannot be overemphasized. The pain and burden of memories of ongoing, recent and past conflicts haunt and hamper normal life and progress. The process for ‘Healing of Memories’ is designed to advocate for, develop and promote healing of memories and other healing and reconciliation processes in Churches and faith communities, so as to strengthen their role as channels of hope, healing and reconciliation in our world today.”

This was part of the final message of the WCC “European Ecumenical and Interreligious Consultation on ´Healing of Memories’ on 4th-6th May 2010”, in Sarajevo, Bosnia-Herzegovina. On the one hand, the Bible leads us to peace and reconciliation, like in Prov 16:7 in the Old Testament: “When a man’s ways are pleasing to the Lord, he makes even his enemies to be at peace with him”, or in the new Testament, when in Cor 5:18, Paul says “All this is from God, who through Christ reconciled us to himself and gave us the ministry of reconciliation.”  Moreover, the European Protestant, Orthodox, Anglican, and Catholic churches avowed in the Final Document of the Second European Ecumenical Assembly in Graz 1997: “The church communities must confess that throughout history they often showed themselves as a bad example for the Christian message of reconciliation and ´religions and churches became themselves part of the problem´.” Therefore, the European churches signed in their common Charta Oecumenica in chapter 3: “In the spirit of the Gospel, we must reappraise together the history of the Christian churches, which has been marked by many beneficial experiences, but also by schisms, hostilities and even armed conflicts.” There have been several church initiatives of reconciliation in Europe, like the Stuttgart Church Confession of Guilt, the reconciliation process between the Polish Ecumenical Council and the Evangelical Church in Germany, the Czechian and German church reconciliation process, the reconciliation process between the Church of Norway and the Sámi, the reconciliation process in Northern Ireland, the process called „Reconciliation in Europe between the Churches in Ukraine, Belarus, Poland, and Germany”, the Anglican–Orthodox Dialog, the Porvoo process between the Anglican and the Lutheran Churches, the Pro Oriente reconciliation process regarding the schism of the “Unions of Brest and Transylvania”. The “Healing of Memories” (HoM) process – originally developed in South Africa as a counselling methodology for the healing of personal emotional wounds after the apartheid – was further developed in South Eastern Europe on behalf of CPCE, CEC, and WCC into a process between cultures and religions. Healing of Memories between cultures and religions is a methodology to help overcome frozen history and “hi-stories” by putting emphasis on voices that were not heard, ignored or not acknowledged so far. According to its methodology, HoM is a “process of the generations” that implicates the three steps of “walking together through history”, “sharing the pain of others”, and “preparing the future together”. The HoM process between cultures and religions adds to the above “three historical steps” the previous step: “Interdisciplinary researching of the history of the nations, cultures and religions and/or communities.” For these HoM processes, special training courses have been developed in Romania in order to train facilitators, which have been recognised and adopted in the meantime as master courses at the universities of Cluj-Napoca/Kolozsvár, Alba Iulia/Gyulafehérvár, and Sibiu/Nagyszeben.

References

BRANDES, Dieter: Healing of Memories – Eine Aufgabe christlicher Kirchen in Europa, in epd-Dokumentation nr. 40 / 2005, Evangelischer Pressedienst, Frankfurt/M, 2005. 16–25.

BRANDES, Dieter – KURIAN, Manoj: Healing of Memories in Europe, in: KURIAN, Manoj – BRANDES, Dieter – LUKÁCS, Olga – GRĂJDIAN, Vasile (ed.): Reconciliation nr. 7 Reconciliation between Peoples, Cultures and Religions. Reconciliation in Bosnia-Herzegovina Compared to European-Wide Experiences, European Interreligious Consultation on ‘Healing of Memories’ Sarajevo, Bosnia-Herzegovina, May 3-6, 2010. 15–26.

BRANDES, Dieter: Zur Methodologie von Healing of Memories und Bezüge zur ethnischen, kulturellen und religiösen Identität, in: BRANDES, Dieter – LUKÁCS, Olga (ed.): Reconciliatio nr. 2.2. Die Geschichte der christlichen Kirchen aufarbeiten, Leipzig, 22011. 23–39.

BRANDES, Dieter – LUKÁCS, Olga: Geschichte der Kirchen Rumäniens in Zeittabellen, in: BRANDES, Dieter – LUKÁCS, Olga (ed.): Reconciliatio nr. 2.2. Die Geschichte der christlichen Kirchen aufarbeiten, Leipzig, 22011. 353–468.

BRANDES, Dieter: The need for Reconciliation in Europe Part I – The Role of the Churches, Historical wounds of Europe, in: Teologia – Revista Facultăţii de Teologie Ortodoxă, Anul XX, Nr. 4(69), Arad, 2016. 44–68.

BRANDES, Dieter: Reconciliation through Remembering – An Overview about the Methodology of Healing of Memories (HoM), in: Revista Teologică, 2/2016, Serie Nouă, Anul XXVI (98), Sibiu, 2016. 272–284.

BRANDES, Dieter: The need for Reconciliation in Europe Part II – The Church´s Ministry of Reconciliation, Reconciliation – a Permanent Concern for the Conference of European churches, in: Teologia – Revista Facultăţii de Teologie Ortodoxă, Anul XXI, Nr. 1(70), Arad, 2017. 82–109.

BROADBENT, Noel D.: Lapps and Labyrinths – Saami Prehistory, Colonization, and Cultural Resilience, Washington, 2010.

Charta Oecumenica, chapter 3 Moving towards one another, in: Charta Oecumenica Guidelines for the Growing Cooperation among the Churches in Europe http://www.ceceurope.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/ChartaOecumenica.pdf, picked up on the 18.06.2020

Chronologie des Völkermords an den Sinti und Roma, in: Roman ROSE (ed.): Der nationalsouialistische Völkermord an den Sinti und Roma, Dokumentations- und Kulturzentrum Deutscher Sinti und Roma, Heidelberg, 2000. https://zentralrat.sintiundroma.de/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/chronologie-des-voelkermords-an-den-sinti-und-roma-1-1.pdf, picked up on the 18.06.2020

COLLINS, M. E.: Ireland 1868-1966, Dublin, 1993.

COLLINS, M. E.: Politics and Society in Northern Ireland 1949-1993, Dublin, 2008.

Conference of European Churches in https://www.oikoumene.org/en/member-churches/europe/cec?set_language=en

CONQUEST, Robert: The Nation Killers: The Soviet Deportation of Nationalities, London, 1970.

COOGAN, T. P.: The IR, London, 1990.

Darmstädter Wort des Bruderrates der Evangelischen Kirche in Deutschland – Zum politischen Weg unseres Volkes vom 8. August 1947, in: Kirchliches Jahrbuch 1945-1948, Gütersloh, 1950. 220 ff.

Der trennende Zaun ist gebrochen – Zur Verständigung zwischen Tschechen und Deutschen, Evangelische Kirche der Böhmischen Brüder und Evangelische Kirche in Deutschland EKD Leipzig, 1998.

Dialog, Versöhnung und Brüderlichkeit, Gemeinsames Wort der Deutschen und der Polnischen Bischofskonferenz vom 13. Dezember 1995, press release of the Roman Catholic Episcopal Conference of Germany, Bonn, 13th December, 1995.

Dokumente wachsender Übereinstimmung. Sämtliche Berichte und Konsenstexte interkonfessioneller Gespräche auf Weltebene, Bd. 1: 1931–1982, Bd. 2: 1982–1990, Bd. 3: 1990–2001 edited by H. MEYER u. a., Paderborn–Frankfurt a.M., 1983–1992.

FISHER, Alan W.: The Crimean Tatars, Stanford, 1978.

GROSS, Alexander: Gehorsame Kirche – ungehorsame Christen im Nationalsozialismus, Mainz, 22000.

HENRIX, Hans Hermann (ed.): Nostra Aetate – Ein zukunftsweisender Konzilstext. Die Haltung der Kirche zum Judentum 40 Jahre danach, in: Aachener Beiträge zu Pastoral- und Bildungsfragen 23, Aachen 2006. 233–237.

IONIŢĂ, Viorel: Reconciliation – A Permanent Concern for the Conference of European Churches, in: GRĂJDIAN, Vasile – LUKÁCS, Olga (ed.): Reconciliatio nr. 4 Telling Stories of Hope – Reconciliation in South East Europe Compared to Worldwide Experiences. Festschrift in Honor of Dieter Brandes to his 65th Birthday, Cluj-Napoca–Leipzig, 2010. 93–98.

JUTIKKALA, Eino: Geschichte Finnlands, Stuttgart, 1964.

Kirchliches Jahrbuch für die Evangelische Kirche in Deutschland 1950, Gütersloh, 1951.

LAPSLEY, Michael SSM: Healing Memories – Gewalt überwinden als Teil der Mission der Kirche, speech June 2002 in Breklum/Germany, unpublished manuscript.

LAVERY, Jason: The History of Finland, Westport-USA, 2006.

LUDWIG, Hartmut: Darmstädter Wort, in: Die Religion in Geschichte und Gegenwart, 4th edition, volume 3, Tübingen, 1999. Column 581f.

Making Peace with the Past, Institute Healing through Remembering, Belfast, 2006.

MARYNOWYCH, Miroslaw: Die Osterweiterung der Europäischen Institutionen – Historische Belastungen am Beispiel der Ukraine in Versöhnung in Europa – Aufgabe der Kirchen in Belarus, Polen und Deutschland, Kontaktausschuss des Polnischen Ökumenischen Rates und der Evangelischen Kirche in Deutschland, Hannover, 1998. 24–37.

MCMASTER, Johnston: Healing of Memories in Northern Ireland, in: KURIAN, Manoj – BRANDES, Dieter – LUKÁCS, Olga – GRĂJDIAN, Vasile (ed.): Reconciliation nr. 7 Reconciliation between Peoples, Cultures and Religions. Reconciliation in Bosnia-Herzegovina Compared to European-Wide Experiences, European Interreligious Consultation on ‘Healing of Memories’ Sarajevo, Bosnia-Herzegovina, May 3-6, 2010. 77–84.

MÖRKENSTAM, Ulf – GOTTARDIS, Andreas – ROTH, Hans Ingvar: The Swedish Sámi Parliament: A Challenged Recognition?, European University Institute Florence, Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies 2012/10. 4.

Neue Gräben in Europa? Versöhnung, Kontaktausschuss des Polnischen Ökumenischen Rates und der Evangelischen Kirche in Deutschland, Hannover, 1997.

Orthodox Anglicanism and Christian Reunion: https://www.pravoslavie.ru/59798.html

Participation in God’s Mission of Reconciliation – A Resource for Churches in Situations of Conflict (nr. 148), Faith and Order Paper 201, World Council of Churches, Geneva, 2006.

RANDALL, David (ed.): The Lambeth Conferences of 1867, 1878 and 1888., London, Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge, 1889.

Reconciliation – Gift of God and Source of New Life, in: RÜDIGER – Stefan VESPER: Documents of the Second European Ecumenical Assembly, Graz, 1998. 51.

SANTAYANA, George: Reason in Common Sense, volume 1. The Life of Reason, 1905, quoted from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Santayana

SIMON, Gerhard: Analyse: 80 Jahre Holodomor – die Große Hungersnot in der Ukraine, Bundeszentrale für Politische Bildung, 28. 11. 2013: http://www.bpb.de/internationales/

europa/ukraine/174179/analyse-80-jahre-holodomor-die-grosse-hungersnot-in-der-ukraine?p=all

SMYTH, Geraldine: Peace Ten Years on: and where are the Churches Now? in: Dieter BRANDES (ed.): Reconciliatio nr. 1 Healing of Memories in Europe, Leipzig, 2008. 156–170.

STEFFENSEN, Rolf: The Difficult Talks – Experiences from a Reconciliation Process of Norway, in KURIAN, Manoj – BRANDES, Dieter – LUKÁCS, Olga – GRĂJDIAN, Vasile (ed.): Reconciliation nr. 7 Reconciliation between Peoples, Cultures and Religions. Reconciliation in Bosnia-Herzegovina Compared to European-Wide Experiences, European Interreligious Consultation on ‘Healing of Memories’ Sarajevo, Bosnia-Herzegovina, May 3-6, 2010. 54–58.

STEVENS, David: Dealing with the Past in Northern Ireland. The Corrymeela House Perspective, in: BRANDES, Dieter (ed.): Reconciliatio nr. 1 Healing of Memories in Europe, Leipzig, 2008. 115–143.

STÜSSI, Anna (ed.): Die Sami: Bedrohte Kultur in Lappland, Bern 1990. published on the homepage of the Associazione per i popoli minacciati – Sudtirolo – Gesellschaft für bedrohte Völker – Südtirol – Lia por i popui manacês Bolzano/Bozen: http://www.gfbv.it/3dossier/eu-min/sami.html

TUTU, Desmond: No Future without Forgiveness, Doubleday, 1999.

VACHICOURAS, Gary: Historical Survey on the International Bilateral Dialogues of the Orthodox Church, Derecho y religión, nr. 3, 2008 (Ejemplar dedicado a: Christianity in Europe). 151–190.

Versöhnung in Europa – Aufgabe der Kirchen in der Ukraine, in Weissrussland, Polen und Deutschland, Kirchenamt der Evangelischen Kirche in Deutschland EKD, Hannover, 2006.

WYBREW, Hugh: The Church of the Triune God: the Cyprus Agreed Statement of the International Anglican Orthodox Theological Dialogue 2006, Internationale kirchliche Zeitschrift, Neue Folge der Revue internationale de théologie, Band 97, Zürich, 2007, Heft 4. 249–274. 260.

Downloads

Published

2020-06-20

How to Cite

BRANDES, D. (2020). The Mission of Christians for Reconciliation in Europe. Studia Universitatis Babeș-Bolyai Theologia Reformata Transylvanica, 65(1), 309–344. https://doi.org/10.24193/subbtref.65.1.17

Issue

Section

Articles